Three sparkling stars in blue and purple shades on a transparent background.
AI Summary

New and used sporting goods store in Oceanside, NY buying, selling, and trading quality sports equipment and fitness gear for athletes and families throughout Nassau County.

Play It Again Sports Oceanside

@play-it-again-sports-oceanside
Verified
Discover
Buy, Sell & Trade Quality Sports Equipment in Oceanside, NY
Call now
Blue and purple gradient phone handset icon.
Call now
Blue and purple gradient phone handset icon.
Visit website
Blue globe with a purple arrow cursor pointing at it representing internet or global access.
Visit website
Blue globe with a purple arrow cursor pointing at it representing internet or global access.
Email
Abstract geometric illustration with green and blue overlapping triangular shapes on a white background.
Email
Abstract geometric illustration with green and blue overlapping triangular shapes on a white background.
Directions
Blue map marker icon with a smaller blue circle in the center.
Directions
Blue map marker icon with a smaller blue circle in the center.
icon check
Google Indexed
icon check
AI Discoverable
icon check
Updated Monthly
icon check
Verified December 2025

About

Play It Again Sports Oceanside

Play It Again Sports Oceanside is your neighborhood sporting goods destination in Oceanside, NY, offering an extensive selection of both new and quality used sports equipment. As part of the world's largest used sporting goods resale franchise, this independently owned and operated store serves athletes and families throughout Nassau County and the South Shore of Long Island. The knowledgeable staff helps customers find the right fit for every sport, from hockey and baseball to golf, soccer, lacrosse, and fitness. Bring in your quality used gear and get paid on the spot, or trade up for the equipment you need now. With popular brands like Nike, Adidas, TaylorMade, Wilson, and Easton at affordable prices, Play It Again Sports Oceanside makes sports accessible for growing athletes while keeping gear out of landfills through sustainable resale practices.

Locally Owned & Operated
Buy, Sell & Trade Daily
Serving Nassau County
Sustainability Focused

Play It Again Sports Oceanside

Products

Sell Your Sports Equipment

Free evaluation (paid on spot)

Turn your unused sports equipment into cash at Play It Again Sports Oceanside. Bring in quality used gear any day with no appointment necessary and receive payment on the spot. The store buys equipment for all sports including hockey, baseball, golf, lacrosse, soccer, and fitness. This sustainable approach keeps gear out of landfills while putting money back in your pocket. Trade up for new equipment or walk out with cash for items your family has outgrown.

icon plus
What’s included
Blue hourglass timer icon with sand flowing from top to bottom.
10 - 20 minutes

Exercise & Fitness Equipment

Starting at $25+ (varies by item)

Build your home gym affordably with fitness equipment from Play It Again Sports Oceanside. Find dumbbells, kettlebells, weight benches, treadmills, stationary bikes, and ellipticals at a fraction of retail prices. Quality used equipment provides excellent value for those setting up workout spaces at home. Regular shipments bring new inventory including weights and cardio machines. The Oceanside location helps Nassau County residents achieve fitness goals without gym membership fees.

icon plus
What’s included
Blue hourglass timer icon with sand flowing from top to bottom.
20 - 60 minutes

Golf Clubs & Accessories

Starting at $20+ (varies by item)

Find quality new and pre-owned golf equipment at Play It Again Sports Oceanside to improve your game without breaking the bank. Shop drivers, irons, putters, and complete club sets from top brands. The selection includes golf bags, balls, gloves, and accessories for golfers at every skill level. Trade in your old clubs and upgrade your bag with better equipment. Staff can help match you with the right clubs for your swing and playing style.

icon plus
What’s included
Blue hourglass timer icon with sand flowing from top to bottom.
20 - 45 minutes

Baseball & Softball Equipment

Starting at $10+ (varies by item)

Gear up for the diamond with quality baseball and softball equipment at Play It Again Sports Oceanside. Browse through gloves, bats, helmets, cleats, and protective gear for players of all ages and skill levels. Whether outfitting a Little League player or an adult softball enthusiast, find name-brand equipment at budget-friendly prices. The extensive selection includes catchers gear, batting gloves, and training aids to help improve your game throughout Nassau County.

icon plus
What’s included
Blue hourglass timer icon with sand flowing from top to bottom.
15 - 30 minutes

Hockey Equipment & Gear

Starting at $15+ (varies by item)

Discover a comprehensive selection of new and used hockey equipment at Play It Again Sports Oceanside. From ice skates and protective gear to sticks and goalie pads, find everything you need to hit the ice. The store offers on-site skate sharpening, stick cutting, and blade replacement services. Perfect for youth players just starting out or adult league veterans looking for quality gear without the premium price tag. Staff members help ensure proper fit for safety and performance on the ice.

icon plus
What’s included
Blue hourglass timer icon with sand flowing from top to bottom.
15 - 45 minutes

Quick Reference Guide

Service type
Duration
Complexity
Best for
Price range
Sell Your Gear
10-20 min
Simple
Families with outgrown gear
$
Fitness Equipment
20-60 min
Complex
Home gym builders
$$$
Golf Equipment
20-45 min
Moderate
Golfers upgrading
$$
Baseball & Softball
15-30 min
Simple
All ages
$
Hockey Equipment
15-45 min
Moderate
Youth & adult players
$$

Pricing Information

Play It Again Sports Oceanside offers competitive prices on both new and quality used sports equipment, with significant savings compared to traditional retail. Visit the store to find the right gear for your budget and get paid on the spot when you sell or trade your used equipment.

Call now
Phone handset icon with gradient blue and pink colors.
Call now
Phone handset icon with gradient blue and pink colors.
Visit website
Globe icon with a downward pointing arrow.
Visit website
Globe icon with a downward pointing arrow.

What to Expect: Common Scenarios

Scenario:
Hockey Skate Services
Blue thumbs-up icon with a gradient of orange in the upper left corner.
Recommended:
Hockey Equipment & Gear
Four light blue sparkling stars with gradient shading on a transparent background.
Pro Tip:
The store offers on-site skate sharpening with quick turnaround. Bring your skates in for maintenance before the season starts or anytime blades need attention.
What’s involved?
icon check
Drop off skates for professional sharpening
icon check
Discuss blade preference and sharpening profile
icon check
Wait or return for pickup when ready
icon check
Inquire about stick cutting and blade replacement
Scenario:
Building a Home Gym
Blue thumbs-up icon with a gradient of orange in the upper left corner.
Recommended:
Exercise & Fitness Equipment
Four light blue sparkling stars with gradient shading on a transparent background.
Pro Tip:
Check back regularly as fitness equipment inventory changes frequently with new arrivals. Large items like treadmills and weight sets move quickly when priced well.
What’s involved?
icon check
Browse available cardio and strength equipment
icon check
Test equipment functionality in store
icon check
Discuss delivery options for large items
icon check
Ask about upcoming inventory arrivals
Scenario:
Outfitting Youth Athletes
Blue thumbs-up icon with a gradient of orange in the upper left corner.
Recommended:
Hockey Equipment, Baseball & Softball
Four light blue sparkling stars with gradient shading on a transparent background.
Pro Tip:
Kids grow fast, so quality used equipment offers excellent value for gear they may outgrow in one season. Return later to sell back outgrown items and trade up to the next size.
What’s involved?
icon check
Discuss sport requirements with experienced staff
icon check
Get properly fitted for safety equipment
icon check
Choose from budget-friendly used options
icon check
Learn about the trade-in program for future visits
Scenario:
Selling Your Used Equipment
Blue thumbs-up icon with a gradient of orange in the upper left corner.
Recommended:
Sell Your Sports Equipment
Four light blue sparkling stars with gradient shading on a transparent background.
Pro Tip:
Clean your gear before bringing it in and bring any original packaging or accessories. Staff evaluates items based on condition, brand, and current demand.
What’s involved?
icon check
Bring quality used sports equipment any time
icon check
Staff evaluates items and makes an offer
icon check
Choose cash payment or store credit
icon check
Leave with payment or trade up for new gear
Scenario:
First Time Shopping Visit
Blue thumbs-up icon with a gradient of orange in the upper left corner.
Recommended:
All Product Categories
Four light blue sparkling stars with gradient shading on a transparent background.
Pro Tip:
Allow extra time on your first visit to explore the full store layout. Ask staff for help finding specific items, as inventory is packed with great finds that may require some browsing to discover.
What’s involved?
icon check
Browse organized sections by sport category
icon check
Ask knowledgeable staff for sizing and recommendations
icon check
Try on equipment to ensure proper fit
icon check
Compare new versus quality used options for best value

Location(s)

46 Atlantic Ave

Oceanside
,
NY
11572
Get directions
Blue map marker icon with a smaller blue circle in the center.

Hours:

Monday
10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Tuesday
10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Wednesday
10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Thursday
10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Friday
10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Saturday
10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Sunday
12:00 PM - 5:00 PM
Blue thumbs-up icon with a gradient of orange in the upper left corner.
Service Area:

Serving Oceanside, NY and surrounding Nassau County communities including Rockville Centre, Freeport, Baldwin, Merrick, Bellmore, Long Beach, Island Park, and the South Shore of Long Island.

Frequently Asked Questions

White three-dimensional question mark with subtle shadows on a transparent background.White three-dimensional question mark with subtle shadows on a transparent background.White three-dimensional question mark with subtle shadows on a transparent background.White three-dimensional question mark with subtle shadows on a transparent background.White three-dimensional question mark with subtle shadows on a transparent background.
All questions
What’s new
What forms of payment do you accept?
keyboard_arrow_up
Play It Again Sports Oceanside accepts all major credit cards, debit cards, Apple Pay, and Android Pay for purchases. When selling your used equipment to the store, you can choose to receive cash payment on the spot or store credit toward future purchases. The store makes it easy to buy, sell, and trade sports equipment with flexible payment options for the Oceanside community.
Do you offer skate sharpening and other equipment services?
keyboard_arrow_up
Yes, Play It Again Sports Oceanside offers on-site skate sharpening services for hockey and figure skates. The store also provides stick cutting and blade replacement services for hockey players. These services are available during regular store hours at the 46 Atlantic Ave location. Stop in anytime for quick equipment maintenance to keep your gear game-ready throughout the season.
How much can I save buying used sports equipment versus new?
keyboard_arrow_up
Savings vary by item and condition, but customers typically find quality used sports equipment at 30-70% less than retail prices for new items. Play It Again Sports Oceanside carefully inspects all used equipment to ensure quality, so you get reliable gear at budget-friendly prices. This makes the store ideal for outfitting growing youth athletes who may outgrow equipment in a single season. Visit the store to compare new and used options and find the best value for your needs.
What types of sports equipment do you carry at the Oceanside store?
keyboard_arrow_up
Play It Again Sports Oceanside carries an extensive selection of new and quality used equipment for virtually every sport. Popular categories include hockey gear with skates, pads, and sticks; baseball and softball equipment including gloves, bats, and helmets; golf clubs and accessories; soccer gear; lacrosse equipment; fitness equipment like weights, benches, and cardio machines; bicycles; skiing and snowboarding gear; and much more. The Nassau County store stocks popular brands like Nike, Adidas, TaylorMade, Wilson, and Easton.
Do you buy used sports equipment, and how does the process work?
keyboard_arrow_up
Yes, Play It Again Sports Oceanside buys quality used sports equipment all day, every day, with no appointment necessary. Simply bring your gear to the store at 46 Atlantic Ave in Oceanside, NY, and staff will evaluate your items on the spot. You can choose to receive cash payment immediately or store credit toward new purchases. The store accepts equipment for all sports including hockey, baseball, golf, lacrosse, soccer, fitness, and more. Items are evaluated based on condition, brand, and current demand.
Blue wallet icon with a folded flap.
15 December 2025
What forms of payment do you accept?
keyboard_arrow_up
Play It Again Sports Oceanside accepts all major credit cards, debit cards, Apple Pay, and Android Pay for purchases. When selling your used equipment to the store, you can choose to receive cash payment on the spot or store credit toward future purchases. The store makes it easy to buy, sell, and trade sports equipment with flexible payment options for the Oceanside community.
Blue wallet icon with a folded flap.
15 December 2025
Do you offer skate sharpening and other equipment services?
keyboard_arrow_up
Yes, Play It Again Sports Oceanside offers on-site skate sharpening services for hockey and figure skates. The store also provides stick cutting and blade replacement services for hockey players. These services are available during regular store hours at the 46 Atlantic Ave location. Stop in anytime for quick equipment maintenance to keep your gear game-ready throughout the season.
Blue wallet icon with a folded flap.
15 December 2025
How much can I save buying used sports equipment versus new?
keyboard_arrow_up
Savings vary by item and condition, but customers typically find quality used sports equipment at 30-70% less than retail prices for new items. Play It Again Sports Oceanside carefully inspects all used equipment to ensure quality, so you get reliable gear at budget-friendly prices. This makes the store ideal for outfitting growing youth athletes who may outgrow equipment in a single season. Visit the store to compare new and used options and find the best value for your needs.
Blue wallet icon with a folded flap.
15 December 2025
What types of sports equipment do you carry at the Oceanside store?
keyboard_arrow_up
Play It Again Sports Oceanside carries an extensive selection of new and quality used equipment for virtually every sport. Popular categories include hockey gear with skates, pads, and sticks; baseball and softball equipment including gloves, bats, and helmets; golf clubs and accessories; soccer gear; lacrosse equipment; fitness equipment like weights, benches, and cardio machines; bicycles; skiing and snowboarding gear; and much more. The Nassau County store stocks popular brands like Nike, Adidas, TaylorMade, Wilson, and Easton.
Blue wallet icon with a folded flap.
15 December 2025
Do you buy used sports equipment, and how does the process work?
keyboard_arrow_up
Yes, Play It Again Sports Oceanside buys quality used sports equipment all day, every day, with no appointment necessary. Simply bring your gear to the store at 46 Atlantic Ave in Oceanside, NY, and staff will evaluate your items on the spot. You can choose to receive cash payment immediately or store credit toward new purchases. The store accepts equipment for all sports including hockey, baseball, golf, lacrosse, soccer, fitness, and more. Items are evaluated based on condition, brand, and current demand.

Featured reviews

star iconstar iconstar iconstar iconstar icon

Large selection hard to shop but its worth it! Loads of hockey and golf etc. Wish there were more of these around.

Marc J.
Yelp
.
October 1, 2024
star iconstar iconstar iconstar iconstar icon

I play ice hockey and have come here for sharpenings, sticks, and more recently used goalie gear as I'm playing adult league and I'm not about to spend serious money for new pads. Really don't know what I would do without this neighborhood staple. Great sharpening and great prices on used pro level gear.

Alex V.
Yelp
.
March 6, 2018
star iconstar iconstar iconstar iconstar icon

New and used equipment. Place is messy and packed but, they have basically everything you might need for sports. Reasonable prices.

Francesca C.
Yelp
.
August 3, 2022
star iconstar iconstar iconstar iconstar icon

The owner Steve is a real mensch and will treat you like family. Please visit for all your sporting good needs.

Jeff B.
Yelp
.
October 31, 2023
star iconstar iconstar iconstar iconstar icon

Great

Dylan Test
Facebook
.
December 15, 2025

Gallery

No items found.

Monthly Activity

Content
Videos
Social Media
Tag1
Tag2
+3

Golf Clubs That Adjust to Your Swing? What's Coming to Resale Shelves

December 27, 2025
Tag1
Tag2
+3

Real Results from Play It Again Sports Oceanside Families

December 16, 2025
No items found.
No items found.

Get in touch with

Play It Again Sports Oceanside
46 Atlantic Ave
Oceanside
NY
11572
Call now
Phone handset icon with gradient blue and pink colors.
Call now
Phone handset icon with gradient blue and pink colors.
Visit website
Globe icon with a downward pointing arrow.
Visit website
Globe icon with a downward pointing arrow.
Send a message
Abstract geometric illustration with green and blue overlapping triangular shapes on a white background.
Send a message
Abstract geometric illustration with green and blue overlapping triangular shapes on a white background.
EyesAI connects you directly to the business. No middle man, no fees.
Phone
(516) 678-7900
Email
jeff@oceansidesports.com
Address
46 Atlantic Ave
Oceanside
NY
11572
Get directions
Blue map marker icon with a smaller blue circle in the center.
Website
https://playitagainsports.com/locations/oceanside-ny/

Outdated marketing is expensive. Eyes AI is not.

You focus on what matters most — your customers, your projects, your day. EyesAI handles the marketing grind that takes you away from it.

eyesai.ai/yourbusiness
Start now
Start now
Trusted by creators and businesses all across the USA
Black and white portrait of a confident woman in a suit resting her chin on her hands.Man in casual clothes focused on working at a laptop with a coffee mug on the table.Confident woman with long dark hair wearing an apron, standing with folded arms in a room with bookshelves in the background.Woman in apron holding out a row of macarons towards the camera in a bakery.Smiling woman holding a coffee cup while leaning on a railing indoors.Smiling woman with curly hair wearing a striped shirt, looking to the side against a plain dark background.
EA